We know D.C. Get our free newsletter to stay in the know.

On first listen, Mi Ami‘s sophomore album, Steal Your Face (Thrill Jockey), seems to begin where last year’s Watersports left off—-quite literally. “Harmonics (Genius Of Love)” practically kicks off midstream, with guitarist and vocalist Daniel Martin-McCormick‘s frantic yelps hitting a histrionic high pitch at the song’s start. If Watersports had been a double album, the C-side could’ve started here.

But listeners will be reconsidering “Harmonics” by the time the next track, “Latin Lover,” slithers along on a guitar groove practically pulled from a top-tier classic-rock tune. It’s the kind of counterintuitive kick in the pants that post-punk fans should know to expect from a band with Mi Ami’s subversive pedigree.

Or maybe they’re just looking for “crazy, off-the-wall musical experimentation.” Or some other post-punk cliché. Which means they may be taken aback about halfway through “Latin Lover,” when Martin-McCormick invokes “I Wanna Dance with Somebody (Who Loves Me)” by Whitney Houston.

That’s exactly what’s great about Mi Ami—-that it will go where other art-punk bands won’t. While 10th-generation Public Image Ltd. rip-offs do their best to reiterate the standard that band set in the late ’70s, Mi Ami—-which has two members who are alumni of the arty D.C. dance-punk act Black Eyes—-does far better bringing in the complexities of pop music and society in the present.

So it’s slightly frustrating. The dub-inflamed sound of Watersports is still here, just not always on the surface. At its heart Steal Your Face is a grower: There’s less of Watersports‘ straight-to-the—jugular immediacy, and more of a spellbinding, slow-burning quality, realized most fully on Steal Your Face‘s closer, the aptly titled “Slow.”

And although the album only contains six cuts, it’s satisfying—-a multiple-course art-punk feast. It’s filling, it’s exhausting, and when you’re ready for more, you can return to it. But that shouldn’t suggest leftovers: Everything here is too fresh.

Mi Ami performs with Maximillion Dunbar and Steve Summers on April 15 at the Velvet Lounge.