We know D.C. Get our free newsletter to stay in the know.

The band on the poster was “Garbage Zone” from Coeur D’Alene, Md., but nobody seemed surprised Saturday night at Comet Ping-Pong when The Make-Up walked out in black suits. “We’re a tribute band,” announced frontman Ian Svenonius to the 100 or so fans. Fine, but it was gratifying to hear a Make-Up that still sounds like The Make-Up—-dirty and slinky and holy-rolling. Agree with Malitz here: The highlight was an immaculately ragged “We Can’t Be Contained,” which is still all build, half release. You can’t beat The Make-Up for that kind of emotional unleashing, which still manages to self-examine and instruct; if there’s a line running through Svenonius’ bands, it’s a pedagogical one. For my money, he’s only honed his wit—-and his lessons for modern-day rock and the people who think about it—-with Weird War and now Chain & the Gang. But music that’s unhinged, too? That’s what The Make-Up’s “gospel yeh-yeh” is all about. The Make-Up reunion—-with original members Svenonius, Michelle Mae, and James Canty plus fill-in drummer Mark Cisneros—-continues May 25-27 in London and Sept. 21-23 in New Jersey; both shows are curated by All Tomorrow’s Parties. Hopefully D.C. gets another date, too.

Saturday’s show also included a set of garage-rock covers by Kid Congo Powers, Tom Bunnell, Brendan Canty, Alyssa Bell, and Cisneros. Check out Erica Bruce‘s photos of both sets here.