We know D.C. Get our free newsletter to stay in the know.

Sweet girl, Julia Stiles, but she sure wasn’t made to utter lines such as “They killed our man!” Her casting as what appears to be a double-secret telephone operator is just one of the misfires that lend The Bourne Identity an amateur feel, despite its overcoming what seemed to be its biggest obstacle: Matt Damon as action hero. (Hell, if his frat-boy counterpart Ben Affleck can fill Harrison Ford’s shoes, I guess anything is possible.) Though watching Damon scale walls Spidey-style and mercilessly kick ass does take some getting used to—especially when the too-crisp whap-pows! of each blow sound cartoonishly exaggerated—his intelligent portrayal of amnesiac CIA assassin Jason Bourne belies his baby face and makes the film’s formulaic putting-together of the pieces interesting, even when the audience already knows what the puzzle will look like. Setting out to find his identity after his bullet-ridden body was discovered floating in the Mediterranean, Bourne relies on his wits and his curious instinct to attack to guide him to clues about his life, including a safe-deposit box filled with a gun, fistfuls of cash, and several passports giving him different names. He enlists the help of down-on-her-luck Marie (an understated Franka Potente) by offering her $10,000 for the use of her Mini, leading to spectacular chase scenes through the tight streets of Paris that are a better advertisement for the newly relaunched compact than BMW’s current campaign. Every time the film moves away from the engaging pair, however, it falters: Director Doug Liman manages to make the inherently slick CIA look anything but, with wannabe-tough CIA head Ted Conklin (Chris Breast Men Cooper) looking especially ridiculous as he tosses off noirish rapid-fire directives to lackeys furiously working their keyboards to hunt down the seemingly traitorous Bourne. And a subplot involving the eventual assassination of the leader Bourne was charged with killing is both extraneous and a poor use for the usually riveting Clive Owen, who plays a nearly silent backup assassin. If only Stiles had gotten that part… —Tricia Olszewski